BROOKLYN! 1951! A year that has never felt so ......boring. Yes folks, this movie sucked. There was nothing to take away from it, nothing memorable, and nothing special.
That's not to say that things didn't happen in it that weren't compelling, but from a narrative perspective, it had no arcs. The entire movie could have been compressed into an opening act no more than 35 minutes long. I kept waiting for things to heat up and for a conflict of some variety to start (as it did in THE IMMIGRANT) but it just never did. This movie is filled with missed opportunities in this capacity (e.g the kid discussing corrupt cops -- you'd think they'd play a roll later on, but they never do).
Then there's the acting...I honestly can't tell if Saoirse Ronan just can't act, or if she keeps getting cast as someone with no personality. I suspect it's the latter, because she does have scenes -- but they come at such bland times that you can't help but roll your eyes.
The characters are all the same note. They have little personality and seem like a 3rd or 4th hand retelling of some grandmother's story of coming to America. Honestly, I could write the ENTIRE plot (and subplots -- or sore lack-thereof) out in as many paragraphs as this review. No hyperbole. Let's do it at the end so we don't spoil it.
The dialogue in Brooklyn was inconsistent. Most scenes felt half-baked, where some of the lines were delivered on beat and with purpose...but the other half were just throwaway lines you'd expect would have been edited out on a previous version. The lines are delivered properly and on beat, but never hold the emotional weight. I can't tell if this was a musical score issue or what, but something just felt dry.
Overall, I'd give this movie a very weak 4/10. It is as cliche as it is forgettable. Skip it.
>girl in ireland
>work at store it suck
>girl go to america
>boat sux no bathroom
>girl lives with ppl they so funny
>girl work at store
>girl do stuff at home
>girl go to dance meet boy
>girl love boy
>girl meet boy parents nothing happen
>girl marry boy
>girl sister die
>girl go home to ireland very sad
>girl meet new boy
>girl not really fall in love
>girl talk to old boss
>girl say bye to mom go back to america
>girl hug husband the end.
>credits